Given that three weeks ago, the NRL had a representative weekend. I thought I would have a look and explain how James Tamou qualified for Australia, what the laws are regarding representative eligibility, what the eligibility laws are in Rugby Union, Football and Cricket and what the RLIF should change them too. Also, I will have a few ideas on how to make the representative weekend a better weekend in the future. I will also look at the possibility of a New Zealand Origin game and how you would split the squads in this special representative edition of the Blog of Cheese.


Even though James Tamou was born in New Zealand, he has been living in Australia since the age of thirteen, making him eligible for Australia not only in Rugby League but also in Rugby Union, Cricket or Football. These sports allow players to play for a country where they were not born yet currently reside, providing they have lived in that country for two to five years. Why the furore erupted in James’ case? This was because he was included in the New Zealand train-on squad last year, as he was born in New Zealand. If he made the squad for the 2011 Four Nations, he would be considered a Kiwi. The fact that James played for the NZ Maori has no significance whatsoever, as the NZ Maori team is a team selected on ethnicity; it has nothing to do with where you live. Rugby League cops unfair criticism from fans of all codes over its leniency to switch countries (two years or the end of the next world cup, whichever is earlier). Compared to cricket, which is four years between test or affiliate countries. In football, a player is only allowed once before their 21st birthday to switch countries and as long as it is not at the senior level. In Rugby Union, a player is not permitted to switch countries once he represents a country at either test, the next best team or his country in Rugby Sevens. Suppose the RLIF adopted the policy of the IRB where a player is not allowed to switch once he reaches the test, next best team or seven/nines level and also scheduled more test matches for the developing nations in the Pacific. In that case, more players will choose the developing nation over the more prominent countries (A summary of the rules used by IRB, ICC, FIFA and the RLIF will be included at the bottom of the article).


During the representative the only weekend, there was a test match between Australia and New Zealand on Friday night, an under 20’s NSW V QLD game on Saturday night and the City V Country game on Sunday, which was a far cry from the eight games on most NRL weekends. For the 2013 representative weekend, I would play more test matches over the weekend, and I would play test matches across both hemispheres, with Super League also taking a representative weekend break. How I would schedule the weekend is as follows:

I would play Australia V New Zealand on Friday night, with Cook Island v Lebanon as a curtain-raiser. On Saturday afternoon, I would play Samoa v Tonga and the 20’s origin game as part of a second doubleheader. Finally, on Sunday afternoon, PNG v Fiji along with City v Country in a third doubleheader. In the northern hemisphere, the games would be England v Exiles, France v Wales, Scotland v USA and  Ireland v Italy. Yes, more players are playing on the representative weekend. However, they don’t have to back up to play club football that same weekend, which was the reason for the representative weekend in the first place. There would also be six games that the Southern Hemisphere television networks could show, compared to the three from this year. It also gives every country a mid-season test in the lead-up to the World Cup at the end of the year, with Lebanon playing as the extra test nation as they are the highest test nation to miss out on qualification for the World Cup.


In recent weeks the possibility of a New Zealand Origin game has again been raised as a way for New Zealand to compete with Australia in a post-Origin test match. Using the 2012 NRL season guide, I tried to split the teams based on where they were born/junior clubs for a North V South island game using only NRL players. However, only four qualified for the South Island, so that idea was scrapped. As an Australian, I did not know how to split the players, so I took to the task of tweeting every single New Zealander on Twitter, thankfully Adam Henry, Sam Lousi, Evarn Tuimavave, Joe Galuvao, Motu Tony, Frank Puletua, Sky News/Prime presenter Tim Evans, Sam Kasiano and Nigel Vagana all responded to my tweet and most suggesting Auckland v Rest or those from NZ V those from overseas.

Based on my rough figures, Auckland has thirty-eight players compared to twenty-nine from the rest of New Zealand. I could not place Frank Pritchard or Jason Nightingale in either team as they were both born in Australia. I played their junior football in Australia (as was the case for Gerard Beale, but given that he is a cousin of All-Black Zinzan Brooke, I placed him in the Auckland team). Born in New Zealand/played junior rugby league in New Zealand has forty-one players v born overseas/played junior rugby league overseas has only twenty-eight players, so based on those numbers, I think New Zealand should adopt Auckland v the rest state of origin concept series played on the same day as Australia’s state of Origin. (Teams and squads for both sets of games will be included at the bottom of the article).

And Another Thing: Given that New South Wales named their State of Origin team tonight and Queensland named theirs on Monday, I thought I’d pick who I think will be included in each team and why I think each player should win selection)

New South Wales

Josh Dugan (The incumbent from game 1 last year and has done little wrong this year to lose his spot)

Brett Morris (One of the best fullbacks in the game at the moment, shifts to the wing given his versatility and being a noted finisher)

Josh Morris (Is back to career-best form, his combination with his twin is an added bonus, as they will know what the other is going to do when defending)

Chris Lawrence (Is one of the better defensive centres in the NRL, and although he hasn’t set the world on fire this year, he might step up on the big stage)

Akuila Uate (One of the first players picked, has been down on form from last year. However, the Origin could be a that big stage for him to shine)

Todd Carney (I feel sorry for the incumbent Jamie Soward; however, Todd is back in 20110 form and has the added bonus of playing with Mitchell from their days at the Roosters)

Mitchell Pearce (The incumbent and the best halfback that NSW can choose, will get the job done)

Michael Weyman (Has been a leader of the Dragons pack in recent years, keeping them at the top of the table and will do the same for his state)

Robbie Farrah (Won his place due to his combination with Mitchell Pearce in City v Country and the niggling injury to Ennis, will be out to prove many doubters wrong)

Paul Gallen (Workhorse, the six million dollar man, wind up the batteries and let him go all day)

Ben Creagh (Won’t get the accolades of other back-rowers but will keep going and could be what NSW need at the back end of each half)

Anthony Watmough (Doesn’t miss a beat, is a great edge player and will be more than capable of stepping up when the heat is applied to start the game)

Greg Bird (Workhorse defender who won’t take a backward step, also a ballplayer which will give NSW plenty of attacking options)

Tony Williams (Will have missed 9 weeks, but you play him in short bursts, which will be almost impossible for QLD to handle)

Luke Lewis (Wins the utility spot due to his ability to play almost every position on the field and could open up the QLD defence)

James Tamou (Is a bit raw. However, he is an Origin player of the future, so it is tough to leave him out)

Tariq Sims (An absolute giant, if played with Tony Williams, could give Queensland plenty of headaches)

Most back-rowers can move into the front row to cover Gallen or Weyman if needed.

Qld

Billy Slater (The 2011 Dally M Medalist, in career-best form, as long as he’s fit, he has the position)

Darius Boyd (Has struggled at his new club, Newcastle, however, he could be back in form once he gets back into camp in a familiar environment)

Greg Inglis (Has been a revelation for Souths at fullback, yet one of the best centres provided he is given plenty of ball and room to move)

Justin Hodges (As long as he is recovered from his injury from Friday night, he should be ready to go, a big-game player who steps up on the big stage)

Brent Tate (Wins the position due to injury but is a proven Origin performer and won’t look out of place on the end of the backline)

Johnathan Thurston (Said after Origin last year he would step into Darren Lockyer’s boots and, judging on club form, looks to have settled back into his natural position)

Cooper Cronk (Moves into the starting side with Thurston moving out one, however, he has shown with his form at Melbourne he could have challenged JT for the number 7)

David Shillington (Missed the 2011 series and had a poor 2010. However, he is back in top gear and ready to lead the pack)

Cameron Smith (The new skipper, one of the best players in the NRL, will lead QLD from the dummy half)

Matt Scott (The best prop in the game last year, hasn’t hit the same form due to injury, though he is close to being back to his best)

David Taylor (Earns his starting spot due to the solid year he has had so far and the start in the test match, combined with Greg Inglis, they could cause NSW headaches all night long)

Sam Thaiday (A workaholic, the type of player who you need in Origin)

Ashley Harrison (Returns to lock the scrum and, even though he hasn’t been great at club level, is another who will shine back in familiar territory

Matt Gillett (Was rookie of the year in 2010 and one of the form back-rowers of 2012, his utility value is an added bonus)

Petro Civoniceva (The veteran in his last series will give Queensland what they need towards the back end of the game and will be sure to lift in his previous season)

Ben Hannant (Another one of the form props of 2011 and is unlucky not to start this year, will keep the intensity of his starting front-rowers)

Ben Barba (The X-Factor, could change a close game or the series with his footwork, wins the utility spot over Daly Cherry-Evans, given his versatility in the backline and the ability to dart out of the dummy half)

Quote of the Week:  The Guardian sums up Australian quick bowler Doug Bollinger: “Doug the rug” has established a cult following after a successful 2009/10 summer spent taking wickets against Pakistanis at Test level. This is akin to claiming to be a ladies man because you sleep with loads of hookers.”

If you want to contact me, you can email me at 1895blog@hotmail.com. Remember to like the page on Facebook to find out when new blog posts are available and the latest news, views and opinion from the world of Rugby League at http://www.facebook.com/1895blog. Also, follow me on Twitter at https://twitter.com/1895blog to get all this plus live and full-time scores from every game in the NRL and Super League.

Till next time,

Cheese

Federation’s qualifications for international players:

Rugby Union: As of January 1st 2000 a player may play for one country in which he was a) born, b) one parent or grandparent was born or c) he has completed 36 months of residence immediately prior to the time of the match. Playing for the country, the next best side against another test country or countries second-best side or for a countries sevens side against another sevens side constitutes playing for said country.

Cricket: Was born in that country, if a player can demonstrate they are in possession of a countries passport, the player is a resident of a country, ie a player has lived in a country for a minimum of 183 days for four years or eleven years. For affiliate nations, played in a minimum of 50% of domestic matches for 3 of the past 5 seasons,  100 days working in cricket in the proceeding 5 years, the player played for that country from under 19 level up under section a. For players who are eligible for more than one country, if it is a full member country, he cannot have played for another full member for four years. For an affiliated country, he is not allowed to play for any country for four years

Soccer: The country of the player’s birth, the country of the player’s parent’s birth, the country of the players grandparent’s birth. If a player wishes to play for another country than which he/his parents/ his grandparents were born, then he must live in that country for 5 years, a player can change countries once provided it is not at the senior level and it is before his 21st birthday.

Rugby League: the country he/his parents/grandparents were born, his principal place of residence for three years, the country which he has gained senior honours in the senior sport. Players eligible for more than one country: When a player plays a Senior International Match for a country, he is deemed to have elected to play for that country. Once an election is made the player may not play Senior representative rugby league for any other country until the end of the next World Cup tournament, or the expiry of two years, whichever is earlier.

New Zealand Origin

Auckland Rest
Kevin Locke Fullback Josh Hoffman
Bill Tuopu Wing Matt Duffie
Sam Perrett Centre Kalia Faifai Loa
Steve Matai Centre Shaun Kenny-Dowall
Manu Vatuevi Wing Glen Fishiahi
Keiran Foran Five-Eighth Benji Marshall
Shaun Johnson Halfback Pia Godinet
Sam Kasiano Prop Sam Rapira
Nathan Fien Hooker Issac Luke
Fuifui Moimoi Prop Ben Matulino
Josh Papalii Second Row Bronson Harrison
Simon Mannering (c) Second Row Adam Blair
Greg Eastwood Lock Jeremy Smith
Alex Glenn Interchange Jared Waerea-Hargraves
Jesse Bromwich Interchange Lewis Brown
Jason Taumalolo Interchange Ben Henry
Jerome Ropati Interchange Russell Packer

Auckland: Gerard Beale, Ben Te’o, Martin Tapau,  Bodene Thompson, Liam Foran, Kenny Bromwich, Marvin Filipo,  Siuatonga Likiliki, Tafega Junior Sau, Justin Horo, Sam McKendry, Leeson Ah Mau, Antonio Winterstein, Lama Tasi, Frank-Paul Nuulausala, Kirsan Inu, Sione Lousi, Elijah Taylor, Ben Murdoch-Masila, Tim Simona, Matt Utai

Rest: Eddy Pettybourne, Ricky Thorby, Dene Halatau, Dean Whare, Tohu Harris, Sika Manu, Kevin Proctor, Sandor Earl, Mose Masoe, Alehana Mara, Steve Rapira, Moese Fotuaka

?:  Frank Pritchard, Jason Nightingale

Junior Rugby League in New Zealand   Junior Rugby League Overseas
Kevin Locke Fullback Josh Hoffman
Bill Tuopu Wing Jason Nightingale
Shaun Kenny-Dowall Centre Gerrard Beale
Steve Matai Centre Sam Perrett
Manu Vatuevi Wing Antonio Winterstein
Jeremy Smith Five-Eighth Kieran Foran
Shaun Johnson Halfback Benji Marshall (c)
Fuifui Moimoi Prop Martin Tapau
Issac Luke Hooker Nathan Fien
Ben Matulino Prop Lama Tasi
Simon Mannering (c) Second Row Frank Pritchard
Adam Blair Second Row Kevin Proctor
Greg Eastwood Lock Dene Halatau
Jason Taumalolo Interchange Jared Waerea-Hargraves
Jesse Bromich Interchange Sika Manu
Lewis Brown Interchange Kirsan Inu
Alex Glenn Interchange Mose Masoe

Junior Rugby League in New Zealand: Jerome Ropati, Ben Te’o, Sam Kasiano, Frank-Paul Nuulausala, Bodene Thompson, Kenny Bromwich, Marvin Filipo, Siuatonga Likilik, Leeson Ah Mau, Sione Lousi, Elijah Taylor, Ben Murdoch-Masila, Matt Duffie, Kalia Faifai Loa, Glen Fishiahi, Pita Godinet, Sam Rapira, Ben Henry, Ricky Thorby, Tohu Harris, Sam McKendry, Alehana Mara, Russell Packer, Steve Rapira

Junior Rugby League Overseas Bronson Harrison, Josh Popalii, Liam Foran, Tafega Junior Sau, Justin Horo, Moese Fotuaka, Tim Simona, Matt Utai, Eddy Pettybourne, Dean Whare, Sandor Earl

Leave a Reply