Earlier this year, the Australian Rugby League Commission (ARLC), the Nine Network and Fox Sports Pty Limited agreed on television rights in Australia for the next 5 years. I will be looking at the deal to see if it was the best deal the ARLC could have. I will also be conducting a review of all clubs and finding out what went right or what went wrong in 2012. At the end of the post, I will have the ladder at the end of 26 rounds, where I thought the club would finish in brackets. All this and more in the latest edition of the Blog of Cheese.


On the 21st of August, the ARLC announced a new TV rights deal with the Nine Network and Fox Sports Pty Limited, worth $1.025 billion ($925 million in cash and a further $100 million in advertising). The deal had come after months of negotiations between the ARLC, the Nine Network, the Seven Network, Network Ten and Fox Sports Pty Limited.

Under the deal, the Nine Network will broadcast: three games a weekend; two on Friday night and one on Sunday afternoon;  three Thursday evening matches over the year;  a standalone test match and City V Country game; the State of Origin Series on a Wednesday night; a night-time Grand Final with a 7:15pm kick-off; the annual ANZAC day game between the Sydney Roosters and the St. George-Illawarra Dragons; two hours of Rugby League content each evening on Channel 94, plus two hours of additional content on Saturday and Sunday morning;  all of its matches will be broadcast live across the nation either on the primary or digital station;  the Queensland Intrust Super Cup; all of its matches will be broadcast in HD from 2014. Fox Sports Pty Limited will broadcast five weekly matches across Saturday, Sunday and Monday; thirteen Sunday evening games with a 6:30 kick-off; the annual ANZAC day game between the Melbourne Storm V Warriors game (except in 2014); three non-NRL matches each week played in conjunction with the Telstra Premiership game (which will be shared between Toyota Cup, NSW Cup and GIO Schoolboys Cup; all games will be broadcast, live ad-free during play and in HD. Fox Sports Pty Limited has also secured the digital rights to stream its five games via IPTV and tablet devices. Both networks will screen coverage of the Four Nations tournament and are forming two-player development academies to train players in the media presentation. Both companies also lost their position as the rights holder to match competing for the network’s bid in the following TV rights.

 

The deal is just short of the AFL’s $ 1.253 billion deal (the AFL deal included internet and mobile rights, something which was not included in the ARLC deal), though it does improve on the previous $749 million deal by $230 million. The main point of talking before the TV rights deal was the magic $1 billion that the AFL got for its deal; it was seen that Rugby League had to also reach $1 billion in its value. In showing how important it was to hit the magical mark, the ARLC put a clause into the contract with the consultancy team negotiating the agreement that if they hit the $1 billion mark, they would receive a bonus. Seeing as getting $1 billion was so important, I think the ARLC didn’t get the best deal they could have. After the deal was announced, it emerged that Network Ten’s deal was over $700 million, four live games (Friday Night, Saturday Night, Sunday Night and Monday Night). It has emerged that Fox Sports Pty Limited were against the deal as they would no longer have exclusive access to Super Saturday, so they would have less than five games a week and would, therefore, pay less, which would mean the ARLC would not get their $1 billion that they had hoped to get. The Network Ten bid is superior to the Nine Network bid, as Network Ten would broadcast four games live nationally, compared to the Nine Network, which only broadcast one Friday night game live. The Nine Network are broadcasting the second Friday night game and Sunday afternoon game on delay, which is unacceptable in the digital age, where results are available at the touch of a fingertip. If Fox Sports had gone along the same lines as it did with the AFL deal and broadcast a Rugby League channel, then Fox Sports would still be able to post all games of Super Saturday live. Network Ten would also help explain the game better in the AFL-dominated states. I believe that the ARLC should have gone with the Network Ten deal; even though it had less money, it would have been better for the game of Rugby League and, indeed, either Fox Sports Pty Ltd or the Nine Network, or maybe even the Seven Network would have picked up the four remaining games.


The time has come for me to have a look back at my 2012 NRL season predictions and see how well I did; the table for where I predicted teams to finish at the beginning of the season is at the bottom of the post, in brackets is where they did finish:

Brisbane Broncos: Started the season strongly, winning their first seven out of eight games, to seamlessly transition into the post-Darren Lockyer era without too much problem. Struggled to win games in the back end of the season, as they only won five games for the rest of the season. Halves Corey Norman and Peter Wallace struggled for form for most of the season. The Broncos would lose to a red-hot Cowboys in week one of the finals in a relatively one-sided game.

Prediction:  At the start of the season, I predicted Brisbane would sneak into the bottom of the eight. They finished in eighth place, losing many games they would not have if Darren Lockyer wore the number six for the Broncos.

Canberra Raiders: Started the season in a loss-win pattern, and this came to a halt with three consecutive losses when star Terry Campese was ruled out for the remainder of the season in the middle of the run. Would struggle for the rest of the season before winning their last five to sneak into the eight. This was mainly due to teams being unable to secure their position on the ladder above them. Would continue their run of form by defeating the Sharks in week one of the finals before falling to the Rabbitohs in poor team performance in week two.

Prediction: I predicted that with a fit Terry Campese, the Raiders would go deep into the eight, after a top-four finish. They made the eight, though they did not dominate the regular season as I predicted they would.

Canterbury Bulldogs: They started the season with a win-loss pattern in the first six rounds of the competition. Would then lose three straight, all of which were close losses, the last two against Melbourne and Manly, which suggested that the Bulldogs may give the 2012 season a shake. The Bulldogs would continue the win-loss pattern over the next two games before winning twelve straight, including return victories against Melbourne and Manly. This all but secured the club’s first minor premiership since 1994. Made the grand final with a strong performance over Manly and Souths before falling to a clinical Melbourne Storm in the grand final.

Prediction:  I predicted the club would return to finals football with Des Hasler bringing his magic touch across from Manly, finishing in the bottom half of the eight. I could not predict how successful Des would be in turning the club around in such a short space of time.

Cronulla Sharks: Started the season slowly, losing to the Tigers in a controversial finish, before losing to Newcastle in a game where both sides looked out of it. They would then go on a five-game winning streak, with new boy Todd Carney leading the club around the park. The club pushed for the top four of the eight before the wheels seemed to fall off after their second bye, mustering only seven points from three wins and a draw. They were forced to make the trip to Canberra to face an inform Raiders, who bundled them out of the finals.

Prediction: I predicted after a massive turnover of players, the club would do well,  though with Todd Carney being the key to success, the club would perform well though would just miss out on the eighth to finish tenth.

Gold Coast Titans: Started the season slowly, winning only three of their first ten games with off-field speculation of the club’s future, undoubtedly having an effect on on-field performances. The club won three straight, and by the end of July, we’re sitting in eighth place, and a return to finals football beckoned. The club would win one out of their last five games to finish in eleventh.

Prediction: I predicted the club would collect the wooden spoon with an ageing half in Scott Prince and a lack of a quality five-eighth. The club would have been happy with new recruit Nate Myles,  who earned club-man of the year, though very disappointed with fellow recruit Jamal Idris who at times looked overweight and disinterested, a far cry from the player who burst on the scene in 2008.

Manly Sea Eagles: Due to work at Brookvale Oval, the club would start the season with a five-game road trip, which started defeating the Warriors in a grand final rematch at Eden Park. They would only win once more in the opening five rounds to the Tigers in Gosford before losing the next three straight. The club would win five out of their next six games. They looked to be showing glimpses that could lead the club to back-to-back premierships. After a hiccup against Penrith, the club would only lose five games for the rest of the season to finish in fourth place. Would lose to the Bulldogs in a close game in week one of the finals, and they would defeat the Cowboys in controversial circumstances in week two before looking very much out of sorts in a loss to the Storm.

Prediction: I predicted Manly would struggle to overcome their road trip to start the season and be playing catch-up football to make the eight. For most of the season, there seemed to be a smooth transition to the Geoff Toovey era from the Des Hasler era. However, a few losses in games which they should have won could be signs of things to come for 2013.

Melbourne Storm: The Storm started their season strongly, winning their first nine matches, to be the front runners of the completion before an unexpected loss against the Sharks. The club would win their next two, then go win-loss before the wheels seemed to fall off, losing their next five straight and moving to second on the ladder during this run. The club would turn the tide against a struggling Panthers, the start of a five-game winning streak, to finish second on the table due to a points difference. Many people still believed that Melbourne would struggle to make the grand final; however, the Storm was clinical in all three of their finals games against the Rabbitohs, the Sea Eagles and against the Bulldogs giving their opponents no chance to win the game.

Prediction: At the start of the season, I predicted Melbourne would continue their redemption to win the premiership after having their 2007 and 2009 NRL premierships stripped from them from the salary cap saga. Even though the Storm denied it was their motivation, they are premiers regardless.

Newcastle Knights: Newcastle would start the season going loss-win for their first eight games before losing Kurt Gidley for the season in the middle of a five-game losing streak. They would then win six out of their next eight games, giving them hope of making the eight. However, they would lose their final three games to miss the eight.

Prediction: I predicted the Knights would finish agonizingly short of making the finals and finish ninth. The Knights struggled for most of the season without Kurt Gidley and with star recruits Darius Boyd and Kade Snowden failing to live up to their lofty signings. The midseason of controversial figure Willie Mason proved to be a masterstroke, as he led the forwards and gave room for their young halves room to create opportunities for their outside men.

North Queensland Cowboys: The Cowboys started with a shock loss to the Titans before defeating the Broncos in a close-fought game through some Matthew Bowen magic. The club would then continue their strong start to the season, winning the next nine out of their first fifteen games. They would then go on to win six out of their final eight games, with only losses to grand final favourites, the Sea Eagles, by two points and in a semi-final type game and the Bulldogs. The Cowboys would account for the Broncos comfortably in week one of the finals before being eliminated in a controversial circumstance by the Sea Eagles.

Prediction: Before the start of the season, I predicted big things from the Cowboys, as I have for the last few years; fortunately for me, they delivered. The combination of Matthew Bowen and Johnathan Thurston led the side all season and was helped by Michael Morgan and Ray Thompson at half-back. Before the season, I wrote that the ageing Aaron Payne and Robert Lui’s off fled incidents may derail the club, but fortunately for the Cowboys, neither hampered their season.

Parramatta Eels: The Eels struggled all season, winning only six games; in Round 5 against defending premiers, the Sea Eagles, Round 13 against the Sharks, and Round 16 (extra time) against the Panthers. After Stephen Kearney stepped down as head coach, the club would make it back-to-back wins against the eventual premiers, the Storm in Round 20 and the Broncos in Round 21. Their final win would come against the Roosters in Round 23. Interestingly four of the Eels’ wins came at home.

Prediction: I predicted the Eels to be down the bottom of the ladder, though I did not think that they would break records for the wrong reasons, including the worst start to the season and their first wooden spoon since 1972. The club struggled with coach Stephen Kearney, the players not gelling, and most of the club playing poorly all season.

Penrith Panthers: The Panthers would go win-loss during the first five rounds before losing their next three to return to the win-loss sequence. They would then go on another losing streak of three before winning back-to-back games against the Roosters and the Sharks. This was followed up by back-to-back losses before winning two of their three games to end a very yo-yo season for the mountain men. Besides their back-to-back wins, one win that will be long remembered is when they defeated Manly at home in a game where the defending premiers were made to look second-rate.

Prediction: I predicted this would be a rebuilding season for the Panthers after losing experienced campaigners Petero Civoniceva, Trent Waterhouse and Shane Elford, as well as gaining a new coach in Ivan Cleary and general manager Phil Gould who continued to re-shape the club. The club showed signs of promise, though it struggled for consistency from key players Luke Walsh, Lachlan Coote and Michael Jennings spending time in NSW Cup.

St. George Illawarra Dragons: The Dragons had a mixed bag of a season, with consecutive wins followed by a string of losses. At times they looked like the St. George of the Wayne Bennett era, playing percentage football and grinding away for the win. At other times they tried to play the new Dragons game, which sometimes worked, but more often it did not. They were the real enigmas of the NRL; when they looked down and buried, they would turn it around and win two games straight.

Prediction: I predicted that even after Wayne Bennett left the club, they would not follow the Broncos and miss the finals after the master coach left. The club struggled with Steve Price shuffling his lineup to find the key to success for the club, including sending Jamie Soward to the NSW Cup. The club also suffered from an extended injury to crucial player Beau Scott, who also seemed to be below his best for most of the season.

South Sydney Rabbitohs: The Rabbitohs started the season with a severe last-play loss to the Roosters. The club would then win three of its next five games, with Michael Maguire’s move of attacking weapon Greg Inglis to Fullback in round three proved to be a masterstroke. Inglis had room to roam and could choose when he wanted to get involved in the play. The club would then win nine of its next eleven games to sit in the top three of the competition, including their last-play win in their return clash with the Roosters. The club would struggle with back-to-back thirteen-point losses, and it looked like it was beginning to feel the public’s expectations. The club would win their final two games to finish third. A nervous-looking Rabbitohs would lose to Melbourne in the first week of the finals, followed by a comfortable win over the Raiders. The Rabbitohs led the Bulldogs before losing half-back Adam Reynolds for the rest of the match, and the Bulldogs took control.

Prediction: I predicted Souths would struggle with question marks hanging over Adam Reynolds’ head. Adam proved me and many others wrong by guiding the club around the park. The club returned to the top four for the first time since 1989. Michael Maguire put in a performance close to winning coach of the year.

Sydney Roosters: The club started win-loss across its first four games before back-to-back wins in rounds five and six. The club would follow this up with back-to-back losses and the end of their run in the top eight for the season. The club would only win four games and one draw for the remainder of the season. They fell to finish in the thirteenth position.

Prediction: New recruit Daniel Mortimer struggled, winning only one game in which he started and drawing another. The Roosters squad of 2012 was very similar to the one of 2011, leading me to my prediction of the fourteenth.

Warriors The Warriors would lose their season’s opening game to the Sea Eagles in a grand final rematch at Eden Park. They would win eight out of their next sixteen games. The Warriors then hit the skids, losing their last eight games, including two after leading by eighteen points and the next two losing by forty points plus, blew any chance they had of making the finals.

Prediction: I predicted the Warriors would make the eight before the season started, given that most of their key players from 2011 were returning. The Warriors lost a lot of experienced players in the off-season. The younger brigade was unable to stand up, combined with being unable to gel with new coach Brian McClennan, which ultimately led to Mclennan leaving at the end of round 24.

Wests Tigers: The Tigers produced a Jekyll and Hyde performance in 2012. After winning the first game of the season, the Tigers would lose their next five games before turning it around to win their next seven straight and the club looking at a top-four finish. The club would win two of their next six games before losing their last three and falling out of the eight.

Prediction: With the addition of Adam Blair to the Tigers,  I predicted they would finish fifth and go deep into September. Star recruit Adam Blair failed to deliver. The Tigers also struggled with Robbie Farrah, who missed games due to injury and personal reasons. Without Robbie or an experienced half, most of the Tigers go forward was put on the fragile shoulders of key play-maker Benji Marshall, who struggled to guide the team on his own.

 And Another Thing: Before I wrote the Season Review, I wanted to write something about the media’s relationship with players and access but wasn’t sure how to approach it. I saw this article yesterday written by ex-Parramatta and Canterbury media manager Ross Smart who summed up the situation pretty well: http://sportsbusinessinsider.com.au/news/category/financial-and-governance/analysis-bravo-to-nrl-for-tackling-big-issues-in-balls-on-the-line-strategic-plan/.

Quote of the Week: Lance “Buddy” Franklin took a spectacular mark on the 50-metre line; who else but Dennis Cometti comes up with this line: “He’s the sort of bloke that tells the fat lady WHEN to sing.”

 

If you want to contact me, you can email me at 1895blog@hotmail.com. Remember to like the page on Facebook to find out when new blog posts are available and the latest news, views and opinion from the world of Rugby League at http://www.facebook.com/1895blog. Also, follow me on Twitter at https://twitter.com/1895blog to get all this plus live and full-time scores from every game in the NRL and Super League.

 

Till next time,

Cheese

 

  1. Canterbury (6)
  2. Melbourne (1)
  3. Souths (13)
  4. Manly (11)
  5. North Queensland (2)
  6. Canberra (4)
  7. Cronulla (10)
  8. Brisbane (8)
  9. St George (7)
  10. Wests (5)
  11. Gold Coast (16)
  12. Newcastle (9)
  13. Sydney (14)
  14. Warriors (3)
  15. Penrith (12)
  16. Paramatta (15)

Leave a Reply