Once again, expansion and relocation are buzzwords in the world of the NRL, with every expert having their opinion on what the NRL should look like. Should we have more teams? Should we have fewer teams? Should some teams move?. All of this sounds familiar. So I thought I would look at the history of relocation, rationalisation and maybe where we all could be headed. All this and more in the Latest Blog of Cheese
On May 8 1973, new NSWRL boss Kevil Humpries told the Sydney Morning Herald about his vision for the future of the NSWRL, including a reduction of teams from twelve to six through amalgamation. Kevin also wanted to add Newcastle, Illawarra, Canberra, Wagga and Brisbane teams.
By the early 1980s, many NSWRL clubs were no longer financially viable. The newly incorporated NSWRL decided that clubs must meet specific criteria to compete. The League kicked out Western Suburbs and Newtown at the end of 1983, and Western Suburbs took the NSWRL to court and were reinstated.
In July 1986, Ken Arthurson proposed a “Super League” to replace the current KB Cup with four or five from Sydney, two from Brisbane, three Country New South Wales teams, Queensland Country and Auckland.
On April 9 1992, a blueprint for the expansion of Rugby League was tabled by the Premiership Policy Committee of the NSWRL, followed in August by an Organisation Review by Dr G. Bradley, which was distributed to the premiership clubs. As it became known, the Bradley Report was central to the ARL replacing the NSWRL as the governing body of the premiership. The report concluded that:
“…to reduce the number of clubs in Sydney, will be very hard for the League to implement given the long-playing traditions of some of those clubs. In the long term, however, it is likely that Sydney is not going to be able to support eleven clubs as it does at present. Therefore in the long term, this is the only viable solution. Sydney based clubs are going to have to move to new areas, merge or be relegated from the League. This is going to be a painful process. In the long term, I believe that the ARL should be looking to reduce the number of clubs in the National Competition to fourteen, thus allowing clubs to play two complete rounds. This will mean, assuming that only four new clubs are admitted from areas outside Sydney, that there will be only five clubs based in Sydney.”
Reducing the number of Sydney teams was put on hold in 1995 due to the Super League War. One of the conditions that the ARL and Super League agreed to was that the NRL needed to be reduced from the then 22 teams to 14 teams by the end of 1999
The expansion of the NRL has long been a discussion among NRL fans for nearly a decade. Since the Gold Coast Titans first competed over twelve years ago, the AFL has added two sides, the A-League has added 5 sides (3 are still going, with 1 on the way), and Super Rugby added one team (yet they have lost one). Since the expansion of the NRL is back at the forefront of discussion, I thought I would look at where the NRL could go, as well as way up the positives and negatives of each bid. As I have stated previously (Rugby League in Australia: State of the Game), the NRL should split from a 16-team league into two 8-team divisions. With 18 teams, I think the NRL should split into three divisions.
Below I will look at every expansion bid, give a history, and analyse each bid’s pros and cons.
The first bid I will look at is one of the failed bids from 2004, which missed out when the NRL expanded to 16 teams, the Central Coast Bears.
The Central Coast Bears can trace their roots back to the North Sydney Bears. North Sydney had decided to leave their then-current home of North Sydney Oval and move to the Central Coast for the beginning of the 1999 season to avoid rationalisation. Due to one of the wettest winters in 1998, the stadium on the Central Coast was delayed, and the move never happened. The previous owner of the stadium, John Singleton, had attempted to offer money to any potential team to relocate to the Central Coast; however, they would have to rename themselves the Bears. In 2004 John withdrew from being part of the bid team, and John also removed the relocation clause. The Central Coast Bears were rumoured to take over the ownership of the Gold Coast Titans; however, this did not eventuate. The club has stated they will play most home games on the Central Coast, with one at North Sydney Oval. North Sydney Bears currently play in the NSW Cup due to a feeder relationship with the Sydney Roosters. North Sydney competes in Jersey Flegg, SG Ball and Harold Matthews as a stand-alone club.
Pros:
- Central Coast is already a substantial Rugby League area, so it will have the support of locals if the club is based on the coast like the Central Coast Mariners.
- Several NRL players are Central Coast juniors and may want to return to the team.
- There are supporters of the North Sydney Bears who stopped following the Rugby League once the Bears were kicked out of the competition. A new Bears team would see them return to support the team
Cons:
- Sydney is already an overcrowded market with 9 NRL teams, 2 AFL teams, 2 A-League (soon to be 3) teams and a Super 14 side, who all compete for fans, sponsorship and general income
- The number of people who would initially become new fans of the game would be minimal, with most fans coming from rival NRL clubs, so the game would not grow a more extensive supporter base.
- The Sydney Roosters have established a link with the Central Coast region through junior representative programs, making any new team would have to force the Roosters out.
The second bid I will look at is the West Coast Pirates. The Pirates previously existed between 1995 and 1997 as the Western Reds (Perth Reds in 1997). Perth was excluded from the NRL after three short seasons as part of the comprise to shrink from 22 teams across the ARL and Super League. In 2006, the WARL resurrected the Western Reds. In 2008 and 2009, the Reds played in the Jim Beam Cup as part of a progression plan to return to the NRL. In 2010, the Reds entered a team in SG Ball. In 2012 the WARL launched the West Coast Pirates, who would replace the Western Reds. Several NRL sides have taken games to Perth, including a double-header in 2018 and State of Origin in 2019.
Pros:
- It would be one step closer for the NRL to be indeed a national game
- It would add a lot of new fans to the game. A lot more fans watching the games on pay TV and free to air, which would increase ratings which in turn would raise the revenue brought in from TV
- With the demise of the Western Force, it is easier for the Pirates to gain a foothold in WA
Cons:
- Considering Perth is not a Rugby League region, the question of how many fans would attend games/become members remains in doubt
- The high cost for the West Coast Pirates to travel across the country every second week.’
- It could take several years, maybe even over a decade, before the side becomes entrenched in the Western Australian sporting landscape.
The third bid I will look at is the Western Corridor bid. The Western Corridor bid was launched in 2010. It covers the regions of Logan, Ipswich City, Lockyer Valley, Toowoomba and the Darling Downs; the club’s heartland region will encompass Ipswich, Logan and Toowoomba. Rugby League has been played in Ipswich since 1909. Ipswich participated in what would be known as the BRL from 1909-11. In 1982, a team from Ipswich joined the Winfield State League. Since 1986, the Ipswich Jets has participated in the BRL/QLD Cup. Logan participated in the BRL/QLD Cup from 1987-2002. Since 2003 Logan has featured in the QRL through an association with the Souths Magpies, with the new side known as the Souths Logan Magpies. Rugby League has been played in Toowoomba since 1919. From 1982-2006 a team from Toowoomba participated in the BRL/QLD Cup. Since 2012 Toowoomba has participated in the Hastings Deering Colts and Mal Meninga Cup.
Pros:
- The area covered by the Western Corridor is one of the fastest-growing areas in Queensland.
- A large Polynesian base in the Logan area
- A second side out of Suncorp Stadium would see a game in Brisbane every week.
Cons:
- The Western Corridor could struggle against the Broncos, who have ruled Brisbane for 30 years.
- The Western Corridor may not gain the support of businesses based in Brisbane.
- Fans in Ipswich/Logan/Toowoomba may not travel to Brisbane.
The next bid I will look at is the Redcliffe Dolphins. The Redcliffe Dolphins have played in the Brisbane Rugby League/Queensland Cup since 1947. The Redcliffe Dolphins have wanted to join the NRL for many years. Part of the reason Redcliffe forced Gold Coast to change from the Dolphins was Redcliffe’s desire to one day join the NRL. Redcliffe is viewed as one of the favourites to join the NRL.
Pros
- The Redcliffe Dolphins are already set up financially, so unlike other recent expansion teams across multiple codes, they are unlikely to face financial difficulty.
- A 10,000-seat boutique stadium that hosts some A-League games and the Intrust Super Cup Grand Final
- If the club expands to include the Moreton Bay Region, it could have a large base of supporters and businesses.
Cons:
- Supporters of other Intrust Super Cup clubs wouldn’t support Redcliffe
- Possibility people who live at Redcliffe don’t travel to Suncorp Stadium, where the majority of home games will be played
- If Redcliffe doesn’t expand to the Moreton Bay Region, it will be a tiny population area and may struggle like Manly and Cronulla.
The final bid I will look at is the Brisbane Bombers. The Brisbane Bombers were launched in 2011, and the Brisbane Bombers is headed by CEO Nicholas Livermore and chairman Craig Davison. Not much is known about the bid.
Pro
- Brisbane has a population of over 2.5 million, which means it could support 2 teams.
- A second side out of Suncorp Stadium would see a game in Brisbane every week.
- A possible chance to attract sponsors who want to get involved with the NRL but can’t get in with the Broncos
Con
- The Bombers have targeted the Moreton Bay and Sunshine Coast regions, though given the Storm has set up a base on the Sunshine Coast, it is unlikely they would accept the Bombers.
- No base to build from
- It could be seen by some as just a publicity exercise.
Other NRL bids have been mentioned, including a Queensland Brothers bid, a PNG team, and a team from Central Queensland. However, I believe none of these bids has a serious chance of ever being entered into the NRL. The Central Queensland bid seems dead, as the website is no longer active. If I had to choose which two sides would join the NRL, I would select Perth and the Western Corridor bid. I would structure it, so the Perth side entered a year before the Western Corridor side.
I believe it would be doubtful any NRL club will relocate. The only way an NRL club relocates is if the side falls over, the NRL takes over the licence for a season then the club is reborn in a different city.
And Another Thing: The NRL has moved club and competition databases for local competitions from SportsTG to MySideline. I cannot complete the 2019 Rugby League blog post because this process is incomplete.
If you want to contact me, you can email me. Remember to like the page on Facebook to find out when new blog posts are available. Also, to find out the latest news, views and opinions from the world of Rugby League. Follow me on Twitter to get all this, plus live and full-time scores from every game in the NRL. As well as full-time scores from; Super League, Canterbury Cup NSW, Intrust Super Cup, Kingstone Press Championship, Kingstone Press League 1, Ron Massey Cup, Sydney Shield, Brisbane Rugby League, Jersey Flegg, Hastings Deering Colts, QRLW, Women’s SEQ Division 1, Harvey Norman NSW Women’s Rugby League, Women’s National Rugby League and Women’s Super League.
Till next time,
Cheese